eBay vs Amazon: where should you sell?

Choosing between eBay and Amazon can make or break your online selling strategy. Both platforms offer massive audiences, but their fee structures, rules, and ideal products are very different. Here is a practical guide to help you figure out which marketplace fits your inventory and goals.

Side by side

	eBay	Amazon
Seller fees (approx.)	About 13–15% final value fee on most categories plus a small per-order fee; lower for some electronics	Per-item or monthly plan fee plus a referral fee of roughly 8–15% by category; many categories are gated
Best for	Electronics, collectibles, parts and anything with national demand	New, sealed retail items and books at volume
Local pickup	Yes	No
Shipping	Yes	Yes
Where	US, CA and worldwide	US, CA and worldwide

Fees change often. Check the official pages: eBay fees · Amazon fees

Fee Structures Explained

Understanding the costs of selling on each platform is vital for protecting your profit margins. eBay typically charges a final value fee of about 13 to 15 percent on most categories, plus a small per-order fee, though electronics sometimes feature lower rates. Amazon operates differently by charging either a per-item fee or a monthly subscription plan fee, in addition to a referral fee that usually runs between 8 and 15 percent depending on the specific category. You should calculate these costs carefully before listing your inventory on either site.

eBay charges roughly 13 to 15 percent final value fees
Amazon uses monthly plans or per-item fees plus referral fees
Category differences impact your total selling costs
Always factor in payment processing and shipping supplies

Best Products to Sell on eBay

eBay has built its reputation on being the go-to marketplace for unique, used, and rare items. It is the best platform for electronics, collectibles, automotive parts, vintage goods, and virtually anything with national demand that benefits from auction or fixed-price listings. Because listing individual items is straightforward, sellers who deal in one-off pieces or used goods will find a very receptive audience here. Buyers often browse eBay specifically looking for deals on pre-owned items or hard-to-find replacement parts.

Ideal for collectibles and rare vintage items
Great marketplace for used and refurbished electronics
Excellent home for auto parts and niche hobby goods
Supports both auction-style and fixed-price formats

Best Products to Sell on Amazon

Amazon is built for volume and standardized retail products. It is the premier destination for new, sealed retail items, private label goods, and books sold in quantity. If you are doing retail arbitrage or wholesale sourcing where dozens of other sellers offer the exact same barcode, Amazon is the natural home for your business. However, many categories on Amazon are gated, meaning you must gain approval and meet specific performance criteria before you are allowed to list items in those areas.

Best for new and factory-sealed retail products
High volume marketplace for books and media
Many categories require approval before listing
Strong fit for private label and brand owners

Shipping and Fulfillment Options

Both platforms handle shipping well, but their fulfillment ecosystems diverge significantly. eBay gives sellers full control over shipping choices, allowing you to use your own carriers, offer local pickup, and set custom shipping rates or free shipping. Amazon offers its own fulfillment service where you send inventory to their warehouses, and they handle packing and shipping for you. While Amazon fulfillment simplifies logistics and can boost visibility, storage fees apply if your items sit in their warehouses for too long.

eBay supports local pickup and flexible shipping choices
Amazon offers streamlined fulfillment services for volume
Sellers manage their own carrier labels on eBay
Storage fees apply to long-term Amazon warehouse stock

Researching Prices Across Platforms

Deciding where to list often comes down to seeing where an item sells for the best net price. Smart buyers and sellers frequently check multiple platforms to gauge true market value before making a move. If you want to streamline this research, BuyLow AI is a free app that compares prices across marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp, Craigslist, Swappa, and more. Using cross-platform price checks helps ensure you never leave money on the table when buying or selling online.

Compare live market values before pricing your items
Check multiple platforms to find the best deals as a buyer
BuyLow AI compares prices across eBay, Amazon, and others for free
Identify profit opportunities by tracking historical sales data

Buy low, sell high: see every marketplace's price in one search.

BuyLow AI searches Amazon, eBay, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp, Craigslist, Swappa and more at once, then shows where to buy lowest and where to sell highest.

100% free. No subscription, no card.BuyLow earns a small commission from some store links, never from you.

Questions

Which platform is cheaper for beginners?

eBay is often considered simpler and slightly more straightforward for beginners because you do not have to pay a monthly subscription fee just to list items. Amazon requires you to navigate gated categories and choose between per-item or monthly plans, which can feel complex when you are just starting out.

Can I sell used items on Amazon?

While Amazon is designed primarily for new and sealed retail products, you can sell used items in specific categories like books, music, and certain electronics. However, the vast majority of used goods and collectibles perform much better on eBay.

Do I need a business license to sell on eBay or Amazon?

Neither platform strictly requires a formal business license to create an account and start selling personal items. However, as your sales volume grows and you meet your state or local tax thresholds, you may be required to register a business and report your earnings.

How do shipping options differ between eBay and Amazon?

eBay allows you to handle shipping independently, offer local pickup, and choose any carrier you prefer. Amazon offers integrated fulfillment services where they store, pack, and ship your items for a fee, though you can also fulfill orders yourself from your own location.

Near you

More reselling guides

All reselling guides