Mercari vs Poshmark: where should you sell?

Deciding where to list your items can feel overwhelming when you are trying to maximize your profit. Both Mercari and Poshmark are popular marketplaces, but they cater to different needs and product types. This guide helps you understand how each platform works so you can choose the right home for your goods.

Side by side

	Mercari	Poshmark
Seller fees (approx.)	A selling fee of about 10% plus card processing; check the current rate	A flat fee on small sales and about 20% on larger sales; check the current fee table
Best for	Small items that ship easily: games, accessories, clothes, toys	Clothing, shoes, bags and accessories
Local pickup	No	No
Shipping	Yes	Yes
Where	US	US, CA

Fees change often. Check the official pages: Mercari fees · Poshmark fees

Understanding the Fees

Fee structures are the most important factor for any seller. Mercari generally charges a selling fee of around 10 percent, plus additional card processing fees for every transaction. Poshmark uses a different model: it charges a flat fee for very small sales and takes a 20 percent commission on sales over a certain amount. Because these rates change occasionally, you should always check the official fee table on each site before you list. If you are selling high-value luxury goods, the 20 percent fee on Poshmark can cut significantly into your profits compared to Mercari. However, Poshmark’s flat fee structure can sometimes benefit sellers of moderately priced clothing items.

Mercari: Roughly 10 percent plus processing fees
Poshmark: Flat fee for small items, 20 percent for larger
Always verify current rates on official sites

What Sells Best Where

Your item type is often the biggest indicator of which platform will perform better. Poshmark is widely known as a fashion-focused marketplace. It is the go-to destination for clothing, shoes, handbags, and accessories. Because the audience there is specifically looking for style, high-quality photos and detailed brand descriptions usually yield faster sales. Mercari is more of a general marketplace. It excels with smaller, everyday items that are easy to ship. If you have toys, video games, collectibles, or home accessories, you might find a more receptive audience on Mercari. While you can sell clothes on Mercari, the platform's versatility makes it a better catch-all for household goods.

Poshmark: Best for clothes, shoes, and luxury bags
Mercari: Ideal for games, toys, and home accessories
Match your inventory to the site's primary audience

Shipping and Logistics

Both platforms simplify the shipping process, which is a major relief for new sellers. They provide pre-paid shipping labels, so you do not have to calculate postage or run to the post office with a scale. On Poshmark, shipping is standardized, which makes it very easy for buyers to know exactly what they are paying for shipping costs regardless of the item weight. Mercari offers more flexibility, allowing sellers to choose between different shipping carriers based on the weight and size of the package. This can sometimes be cheaper for lighter items, but it requires you to be slightly more attentive when selecting the shipping method during the listing process.

Both offer pre-paid, simple shipping labels
Poshmark uses standardized, predictable shipping
Mercari offers flexible carrier options

The Buyer Experience

For buyers, both platforms offer a secure way to shop for secondhand goods. Poshmark feels more like a social shopping experience, where users can share listings and follow closets, which encourages community engagement. Mercari feels more like a traditional search-driven marketplace. If you are a buyer, you might want to use a tool like BuyLow AI, which is a free app that compares prices across various marketplaces, including Mercari and others. This helps you ensure you are getting the best deal regardless of which site the item is listed on. Both sites hold funds securely until the buyer receives the item, protecting everyone involved in the transaction from fraud.

Poshmark emphasizes social sharing and community
Mercari functions like a standard search engine
Use BuyLow AI to compare prices across platforms

Geographic Availability

It is important to check where each platform operates, as this dictates your potential customer base. Mercari is currently available for users in the United States. Poshmark has a slightly broader reach, operating in both the United States and Canada. If you are a seller in Canada, Poshmark is your primary choice between the two. For sellers in the United States, you have the luxury of choosing either platform. Keep in mind that some sellers choose to cross-list their items, meaning they post the same item on both platforms to reach the widest possible audience. Just remember to delete the listing from one site immediately after it sells on the other.

Mercari: Available in the United States
Poshmark: Available in the United States and Canada
Consider cross-listing for maximum visibility

Buy low, sell high: see every marketplace's price in one search.

BuyLow AI searches Amazon, eBay, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp, Craigslist, Swappa and more at once, then shows where to buy lowest and where to sell highest.

100% free. No subscription, no card.BuyLow earns a small commission from some store links, never from you.

Questions

Can I sell the same item on both Mercari and Poshmark?

Yes, many sellers cross-list their items to reach more potential buyers. However, you must be very diligent. As soon as an item sells on one platform, you need to manually remove the listing from the other site immediately to avoid double-selling and potential account penalties.

Is it safer to sell on Poshmark or Mercari?

Both platforms are generally safe for users. They both provide secure payment processing and protect sellers by holding funds until the buyer confirms the item has arrived. Always communicate through the app, never take payments outside of the platform, and keep your shipping receipts.

Which platform is easier for beginners?

Both are quite user-friendly. Poshmark’s standardized shipping makes it slightly easier for beginners who do not want to worry about choosing carriers or weighing packages. Mercari is also very simple, but its flexibility regarding shipping methods requires just a little bit more attention to detail.

Does Poshmark or Mercari have lower fees?

It depends on the price of your item. Poshmark takes a flat fee for small items and 20 percent for larger ones. Mercari typically takes around 10 percent plus processing fees. Calculate the exact math based on your item's price to see which one leaves you with more profit.

Near you

More reselling guides

All reselling guides