How to flip video games: buying, pricing and selling

Flipping video games is a great way to turn your hobby into extra income or fund your own gaming habits. Success comes down to knowing what items hold their value, spotting a fair deal, and listing your items clearly. This guide covers the essential steps for buying, pricing, and selling video games safely and effectively.

Knowing Which Games Hold Value

Not every old video game is worth money, so you need to learn which titles and genres command higher prices on the secondary market. RPGs, rare horror games, and first-party Nintendo titles usually retain their value much better than yearly sports releases. Pay attention to complete-in-box items, as games with their original manuals and undamaged cases sell for significantly more than loose cartridges or scratched discs. Researching franchise popularity and historical sales data helps you avoid buying worthless inventory that will just sit on your shelf.

Focus on first-party Nintendo and RPG titles
Complete-in-box items sell for more money
Avoid yearly sports game releases
Check for original manuals and undamaged cases

Sourcing Games Locally and Online

Finding profitable inventory requires patience and regular checking across multiple different sourcing platforms. Yard sales, thrift stores, and flea markets often yield the best margins if you arrive early and look through unorganized bins. Online marketplaces like Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp, and eBay are great for finding local bundles or mispriced listings. Always be ready to act quickly when a good deal appears, but never rush into a purchase without verifying the condition of the disc or cartridge first.

Check garage sales and thrift stores early
Look for local bundles on classified apps
Inspect discs and cartridges before paying
Negotiate polite and fair prices with sellers

Pricing Your Inventory Accurately

Pricing your items correctly is the delicate balance between making a profit and waiting months for a sale. You should always check recent completed listings rather than active asking prices to see what buyers are actually paying. Tools like the BuyLow AI app can help you quickly compare current prices across marketplaces like eBay, Mercari, and Amazon to find the sweet spot. Factor in platform fees, shipping materials, and your time when calculating your potential profit margin on every single game you list.

Check sold listings instead of asking prices
Factor in platform fees and shipping costs
Compare prices across multiple marketplaces
Leave room for small price drops over time

Cleaning and Testing Your Items

Buyers expect their games to work properly and arrive in clean, presentable condition. Test every cartridge and disc on original hardware before listing them to avoid costly returns and unhappy customers. Use safe cleaning methods, such as isopropyl alcohol on cotton swabs for cartridge pins, and gentle microfiber cloths for dirty discs. Taking the extra ten minutes to clean a dusty case or replace a broken plastic shell can easily increase your final sale price and build a strong seller reputation.

Test every game on actual hardware
Clean cartridge pins with isopropyl alcohol
Wipe down plastic cases with mild soap
Replace broken or cracked jewel cases

Writing Clear and Honest Listings

Clear communication builds trust with buyers and prevents misunderstandings that lead to returns or disputes. Write descriptive titles that include the exact game title, platform, and whether the item is complete or loose. Take bright, well-lit photos from multiple angles, and include close-up shots of any scratches, label damage, or manual tears. Being completely honest about flaws upfront saves you time and attracts buyers who appreciate transparency.

Include platform and completeness in titles
Take bright, clear photos of the actual item
Document any scratches or label damage
Mention missing manuals or damaged boxes

Packing and Shipping Securely

Protecting your items during transit ensures they arrive safely and prevents damage that could ruin your profit. Wrap disc cases in bubble wrap and use sturdy cardboard boxes or bubble mailers depending on the item size. For loose cartridges, a small box or padded mailer usually provides enough protection against rough postal sorting machines. Always purchase tracking and appropriate shipping insurance for higher-valued games so you are covered if the package goes missing.

Wrap fragile items securely in bubble wrap
Use sturdy cardboard boxes for expensive games
Always purchase tracking for shipped orders
Consider insurance for high-value sales

Buy low, sell high: see every marketplace's price in one search.

BuyLow AI searches Amazon, eBay, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp, Craigslist, Swappa and more at once, then shows where to buy lowest and where to sell highest.

100% free. No subscription, no card.BuyLow earns a small commission from some store links, never from you.

Questions

How much money do I need to start flipping video games?

You can start flipping video games with a very small budget of twenty to fifty dollars. Many beginners start by selling games they already own to build up initial capital. Once you make your first few sales, you can reinvest the profits into buying larger bundles and better inventory.

Are sports video games worth flipping?

Generally, sports video games are not worth flipping because new versions come out every year and the older titles quickly lose value. Most sports games sell for just a few dollars and are very difficult to resell for a profit. It is usually much safer to focus on role-playing games, action-adventure titles, and classic Nintendo franchises.

What is the best way to clean dirty game discs?

The best way to clean a dirty disc is by wiping it gently with a clean microfiber cloth using straight lines from the center out to the edge. Avoid wiping in circular motions, as this can create scratches that affect playback. If the disc is very dirty, a small amount of water or isopropyl alcohol can help remove grime.

How do I handle returns as a seller?

Always test your games before listing them to minimize the chance of a return. If a buyer does request a return because an item arrived damaged or not as described, respond politely and follow the platform return process. Clear descriptions and honest photos are your best defense against unnecessary return requests.

Near you

More reselling guides

All reselling guides